The next tactic in the War on Christmas
from Amanda @ Pandagon 19 Dec 2005 7:32 pm
This is where we admit up front that the tradition of gift giving is really an awkward and oft-times awful one. Slate has a couple of advice articles up on gifts not to give, and I think the advice is pretty sound, especially Jon Katz's important reminder that dogs are not good gifts. Amanda Fortini addresses the ongoing problem of people who think that there's exactly no problem with buying clothes they themselves would like for people that have different tastes than them. I'm not as strongly against the practice of giving clothes as gifts as she is, since I think I know a lot of people who are pretty good at doing it, but in general, she's right--about 95% of gift horror stories you will hear involve clothing purchases of one sort or another. Fortini has a pretty funny horror story like this:
During one recent Christmas, I opened a gift from my mother to find a nightshirt printed with an image of dancing books and the sentence "A Booklover Never Sleeps Alone." (It had been a chaotic year; she had clearly done her shopping at Hallmark, likely 12 hours earlier.) I wanted to respond, "If she wears this nightgown she certainly does," but I refrained, smiled, and announced, "I LOVE it!" while my sisters gazed on in sympathetic horror.
She accurately points out that the real danger of the clothing gift is that unless you know exactly their size and taste, you are really treading on insulting someone with your gift. I had a similiar situation to this story once when an aunt of mine gave all the women in our family a gift of a sexy silk nightgown....well, all the women but me and my sister. We got boxer shorts. Three guesses as to whether or not we found this refreshingly charming or were suddenly concerned that she was trying to send us the message that we somehow failed in the sexy and feminine department.
And all that's not to mention trying to find a way to look enthusiastic and grateful when you open a box only to find a sweatshirt decorated with a Christmas tree or a bunch of kittens with sparkles or something. I suppose you could strike the middle ground between saying, "What the fuck?" and saying, "I've never seen anything so beautiful in all my life" through deadpan sarcasm that hides your irritation. "It's wonderful, I'll wear it on my next date with some stirrup pants and a big bow in my hair." I would try this, if not for being a cowardly sort who instead runs off to my blog and makes fun of glitter kitten sweatshirts instead.
Luckily, my mother is the sort who bypasses the whole charade that giving gifts is about surprising people and admits openly it's a materialistic frenzy and just asks her assorted no-longer-minor children just to provide lists of things we want. This is the sort of sensible, no-bullshit approach to Christmas that my romantic self just can't quite bring herself to take yet. I want people to be surprised, which I suppose to be honest just means that I want them to swoon with amazement at my good taste. Which is probably the same motivation that leads people to buy me sparkle kitty sweatshirts, I guess.
Gift-giving: An exercise in egotism, 90% of the time. But to be fair, it's the good, generous kind of egotism, not the bad kind that makes you turn saying "Merry Christmas" into an anti-liberal-call-to-arms.
So, gotta a funny bad gift story? Please tell me I'm not the only one who had gender anxieties provoked against my will on Christmas Day.












