Community hubs

This is the global Feminist Blogs aggregator. It collects articles from many smaller community hubs within the Feminist Blogs network. For stories from particular places, groups, or other communities within our movement, check out some of these sites.

Posts tagged Narrative

Can the Princess Narrative Please Die Already

God's Little Princess Devotional BibleDominant discourse within the institution of religion tends to paint an image of women as docile servants of man and the lord. This is why religion, for the most part, makes me squeamish and uncomfortable. I just can’t get down with the idea that women are a bunch of damsels in distress.

Too bad Sheila Walsh thinks otherwise.

In Sheila’s recent book, Gods Little Princess Devotional Bible, she positions young women as entirely reliant upon the lord to determine their own self worth. Identifying young women as the princess-daughters-of-the-lord plays into age old stereotypes of women as nothing more then an extension of man. Within this conceptual framework, it is impossible for women to manifest their own self worth outside of their relational ties to God. Sheila asks the question, “what girl wouldn’t want to be a princess?” Well Sheila, I can think of quite a few. You know, the one’s that want to be – I don’t know – astronauts, pilots, doctors, lawyers, or maybe even professional feminists. lol. The point being that you can’t wrap young women’s viability as moral actors up in this fantasized narrative about serving God, particularly based on totalizing generalizations about women’s “natural” virtues. Dodai, at Jezebel, highlights exactly how this dominant narrative positions women as subservient. She states,

Furthermore, regardless of the religious message, teaching a girl to be a “daughter of a King” is troubling as it means that the little girl’s identity is fully linked with that of someone else. In this case, the King is God, but all princesses have this problem: A princess is a daughter, a wife or an heir — not an individual. She defines herself by who she in relation to another. Plus, while a warrior goes out on adventures and experiences the world, a princess usually stays in her castle.

On top of that, the language of the text is only the half of it. Giving the big middle finger to any possibility of a gender-neutral book cover, Sheila chose to present the text in pink accents and a tiny tiara. Because of course “virtuous women” must love pink. ugh. Here is a more detailed description of the book,

The characteristics focused on in this Bible storybook will help your little girl blossom into the princess she was created to be. Virtues to create beauty such as compassion, sharing, and truth are highlighted in fun and engaging ways. The perfect format for girls to learn about their destiny as a daughter of their King.

I’m not trying to say that religion is bad. It’s not my place to tell anyone else what they can and can’t spiritually believe, however; selling the idea that young women are daughters of their king drives home the notion that women’s identity is entirely wrapped up in their relationship with a higher power. It creates a detrimental power relationship of dominance and sub ordinance that places women as servants for the purpose of man and God. I’m sorry, but I can’t get down with that. In addition, it gets even worse when you take a look at the version of this book intended for young boys. It’s called, God’s Mighty Warrior Devotional Bible. The book’s description goes a little like this,

Just like God created little girls in a special way, He created little boys to be mighty warriors… even when they feel small. Now with this new devotional Bible in storybook format, boys can learn how to be strong, honorable, courageous and true. Selections of Bible text from the International Children’s Bible are combined with delightful articles to help a budding warrior earn his armor.

Gotta love how women get the short end of the stick in this sexist and sensationalized narrative. While young girls should sit around focused on being beautiful and virtuous servants of the lord, young boys should be learning how to be honorable moral actors in the world. The whole story completely sidelines women’s agency for the purpose of selling some romanticized story about God.

I am completely disturbed that anyone would even consider reading these books.

Coming Out: Rupturing Heteronormativity & Opening Possibilities for Resistance

national coming out Serena’s story inspired me to share my own coming out experience in honor of coming out month and the march for equality in D.C. this weekend. Coming out, as well as sharing those experiences with others, can be a liberating and self-actualizing process. It’s important to note, though, that the coming out process is not universal, nor is it something that we can all understand in similar ways. Attaching to the notion that we are all categorized because of sexual orientation seeks to ignore the infinite ways in which our lived experiences shape our lives in significantly different ways. With that being said, my comments here are not intended to essentialize coming out; to assume that my experience is the same as every gay, lesbian, trans identified, bisexual, asexual, curious, or queer person is to make a whole host of assumptions that are not only incorrect, but problematic in terms of opening space of possibility for gender and sexuality.

With that being said, I do think there are a lot of positive qualities about the sharing of knowledge production and self-discovery. Separating ourselves based on our differences closes off the possibility of building ethical human relationships based in compassion for one another’s lives. Coming out narratives seek to build bridges of intimacy between the sharer of experience and the reader who internalizes their struggle. These stories denaturalize heteronormativity because grief, in terms of who visibly receives it, is concentrated to certain people and places on the globe. The story of Gwen Araujo, for instance, exemplifies the tragic reality that gender violence is treated as a lenient crime within our social and political institutions. The lives of those living outside of strict confinements regarding gender and sexuality are reduced to sub-human status making violence against them not only possible, but justifiable.

To acknowledge the material reality of the other, and to avoid deliberate deafness to the voice of those who are not normally grieved, we have to confront the political task of making the marginal central in the development of an alternative framework. National Coming Out Month is vital in this sense because it makes visible what is currently banished to the periphery. Coming out narratives seek to break the public/private divide by challenging heteronormative assumptions about sexuality being a private issue, unrelated to political and public life. If Bill Clinton’s recent flop on gay marriage shows us anything, it’s that opening others to narrative has the possibility of decentering them from their heterosexual privilege. This isn’t to say that our obligation as a sexually oppressed people is to go around convincing the hetero’s of our viability, but rather, that the sharing of experience holds within it a revolutionary possibility of fundamentally altering human relations.

I remember my coming out story like it was yesterday. It was the summer after my senior year of high school, a time in my life when I was finally open to the limitless potential of who I could become. After spending 18 years of my life growing up in a socially and political conservative climate (Bakersfield….egh), where bumper stickers shouting in bold print, “God Burns Fags,” was the norm, I was ready for a different climate. California State University Long Beach was my college of choice, and the summer offered me an opportunity to visit the campus, figure out my living situation for the fall semester, and meet a whole host of new friends with progressive ideologies. As a disclaimer, at this point in my life I was already tuned into the possibility of being gay. I mean, let’s be real, I spent my high school career hanging out with women, reading feminist international relations in policy debate, and rocking out to Beyonce on the regular. On top of that, my random high school rendezvous with women clued me in on my lust for the cock real fast.

At this point in my life I was already coming to terms with my sexuality. When you spend your entire life fantasizing about men and then convincing yourself that it’s a phase, you eventually figure out that repressing those feelings is not only impossible, but also painful. I still hadn’t told anyone. I was secretly reading gay erotic literature and silently internalizing my fear of the public reaction to who I am.

In August, the month before school started, I was invited down to a party in long beach that was being hosted by my future roommates, Jen & Aly. We spent the entire night getting lush over cocktails and getting to know each other. I think it was after I started shaking my ass in the living room to a Britney Spears song that both Aly and Jen decided to grab me and take me into a back room. They proceeded to ask, “Are you gay?” Without hesitation I blurted out, “yes, yes I am.” From that moment on, it became increasingly comfortable for me to say it out loud and be proud of it.

About a year later I came out to my family. I think my mother already knew, but she cried regardless. My mom was crying because she was so happy that I finally felt comfortable enough to tell her about the aj bottled up inside, waiting to break free. She told me she was proud of me and that her love for me was unconditional. “Nothing as trivial as sexual orientation could ever change the love I have for you,” she replied. I was fortunate enough to have the love and support of my family, which made the world of a difference.

Although this is a reflection of when I “came out,” it is certainly not a complete description of my coming out experience. For me, coming out is a daily activity. In a heteronormative culture that defines sexuality in rigid terms of male-female relations, coming out is a regular part of our every day lives. When we aren’t busy coming out, someone else in the world is; our neighbors, friends, parents, grandparents, aunts, uncles, sisters, brothers, cousins, co-workers, teachers, students. The stories are limitless; each of them sharing with us a different experience of resistance. For that reason, I wanted to share the stories of people who I know, and whose stories continue to impact my life in meaningful ways.

Kristina Bell shares her story,

I came out when I was 18. It was my freshman year of college, my first semester. My mother and I were shopping, and we went to Wendy’s for lunch. She sat down and asked me, “So are you Lesbian, or what?” And I replied … “Yes.” My mom didn’t scream or cry or anything to my face, she was just like “uh, why?” And then didn’t let me talk. Over the weeks, I had some terrible medical issues that meant I was spending a lot of time going back and forth between Long Beach and Bakersfield because my mom’s office provided testing that I would have otherwise not been able to afford. During that time, my mother told me I was not welcome home for the Winter Break. She threw a prayer book at me. She and my sister told me I’m going to hell. My dad made jokes about trying to steal my girlfriend. So, coming out was at the time, really terrible as far as my family was concerned. But, I had Aj, Aly, Katie, Amanda (likes Dragons), and Sarah Crach around me to make me feel comfortable and like a normal person, and most importantly – loved. I feel like coming out made a lot of my friendships stronger, but put a strain on my family relationships.

Now, I prefer to just BE out.

Anthony shared his story,

Still haven’t officially told family, though I suppose it’s an open secret.

As for friends – the summer after my Junior year of high school I went to a speech camp in West Texas. I got “pretty friendly” with one of the other campers and since I was the only person from my school I didn’t feel the need to be secretive about it. Over the course of the next year other speechies from El Paso told my teammates, who told people in my school. Only people close to me had the nerve to ask if the rumors were true, so I never had to out-and-out lie to anyone.

It’s a little unconventional, I guess, in that I never “came out”, but at the time I was 17 and in a conservative (and heavily Catholic) area and I was always so angry – angry that I couldn’t be open, angry that people bullied me, angry that I felt excluded, angry at the kids who would openly say in class (in front of teachers who never bothered to admonish them) that they would kill their gay sons or that the US should ship all the gay people to Afghanistan and nuke the country, that I refused to participate in the process altogether because if straight people didn’t have to do it, then I sure as fucking hell wouldn’t either.

Christine Parker writes,

I had had a crush on my straight best friend in high-school for a very long time… and she didn’t know. But, she was curious to know what it felt like to kiss a girl. So one day after debate practice, she kissed me. She pulled away, I wanted more, and she noticed. We talked later and she asked, “So, what… are you bi, then?” I skirted around the question (because I didn’t want to admit it), but as I was rambling, I began to realize that I shouldn’t deny it. I ended up telling her, “I think of it more as gender-blind, but yeah… I guess I am bi.” She hugged me and told me that no matter what I was, we’d still be best friends.

I told my mom after having cried my eyes out watching “Milk” at the movies. I just sat her down and told her that the movie really inspired me to be honest with her. She wasn’t mad or angry or anything. To be honest, I felt like she didn’t care at all. She told me that she thought it was a, “personal issue that people don’t need to talk about” and continually asked me if I, “was sure.” This happened in February – we haven’t talked about it since.

Clint Osterholz’s story goes like this,

I came out three times. Once on accident, once unintentionally, and once with purpose. When I was in 7th grade, my mom found some porn I’d been looking at which was gay. Although I didn’t know it at the time, she took that as my coming out–and also took my internet away. Then in 9th grade, I confessed to her that I had a crush on a boy at school, which in my mind was confessing my bisexuality. She gave me wise counsel, and I never mentioned it again. And lastly, in 10th grade, I told my mom that I was gay. She sort of blinked at me, sweating and tingling with anxiety as I was, and said softly, “Yeah, uh, you told me awhile ago.”

I can’t help but end with a quote that has helped me through some of the toughest parts of coming out. Audrey Lorde writes, “I have come to believe over and over again that what is most important to me must be spoken, made verbal and shared, even at the risk of having it bruised or misunderstood.”

Coming out is a process that every person reserves the right to come to on their own terms. I just hope we can continue to reshape our culture in a way that is inviting of that process.

The Beer-ometer Says: Obama’s Triangulation of Beer Choices at Tonight’s Gates-Crowley Summit is a Frighteningly Clintonesque Move

So, if you haven’t heard, Obama’s drinking Bud Light at tonight’s “Beer Summit,” which brings together Henry Louis Gates Jr. and Cambridge Sergeant James Crowley in an attempt to seize a “teachable moment” on race relations. Unfortunately, if this moment is teaching us anything about race in America, it’s that we don’t know how to talk [...]

[This is a content summary only. Click on the headline for full links and additional content. Thanks!]

“You Make Mistakes. You’re a Machine”: Deconstructing Robot Love in “Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles” and Beyond

Lately, we have been inundated with science fiction narratives that have been exploring our collective love/fear obsession with technology in a new light. “Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles,” “Battlestar Galactica,” and (a little ways back) “The Matrix” trilogy of films all envision a world in which humans and machines — as distinct races —...

[This is a content summary only. Click on the headline for full links and additional content. Thanks!]

We Should All Be “In Treatment”

After a few fits and starts, according to Michelle Orange of the New York Times, HBO’s series “In Treatment” begins its second season tonight.  We are back in the life of Paul Weston, a psychoanalyst played by Gabriel Byrne, and his patients, whose individual sessions occupy each 30-minute episode. You might never have heard of it [...]

[This is a content summary only. Click on the headline for full links and additional content. Thanks!]

Is Joss Whedon a Feminist Genius or a Mad Pop Culture Scientist? Or, How Long Is It Going to Take to Build This Dollhouse?

I’m still watching Joss Whedon’s “Dollhouse,” and I’m becoming mildly intrigued. Television reviewers had only been given episodes 1-3 when they made their initial, mixed at best, reviews of the series. I wanted to wait until I got through episode 4 before I starting making any pronouncements. So now here’s a tepid one. The story has [...]

[This is a content summary only. Click on the headline for full links and additional content. Thanks!]

Because Googling lyrics is cheaper than therapy

Some time ago, I tweeted, “I really need to find a way to sort out which of the voices in my head I should be listening to, and which I should ignore.” Lest anyone imagine I was joking, I present the following, composed, yes, entirely on my blackberry this morning (with a few edits/link and file insertions) - or, shall I say, afternoon - after long, fitful dreams into which I could not, finally, collapse until well past dawn (the insomnia thing is killing me lately), because it was too important then, for me to wait for my computer to fire up. (Which is happening a lot lately. I swear I’m doing 80% of my writing entirely on my phone, and when I choose to share it, posting directly from there to my Medium Sized Blog - relative to the bloated largess of this one - on Tumblr.)

__

Image: Tears spilled listening to Sad Songs for Dirty Lovers & reading email, taken with the crap phone I had back in June.

Pertains to different album by The National than is referenced here, but it's still apt.

Pertains to a different album by The National than is referenced here, but image is still apt.

__

Some notes on waking, early one Saturday afternoon

Why go to your shrink, when you have the song that’s been stuck in your head for going on 72 hours, which, even though you love the voice of the man who sings it, is getting excessive, so finally you Google the lyrics and then freeze, with a certain horror of recognition, on reading this (on your blackberry, while you are still on the potty)?: If I were a spy in the world inside your head/ Would I be your wife in the better life you led?1

For context: In 1990, when I was first with my future husband (whom I’d first met when we were ages 3 and 4, respectively, and again in 1984, when I was 13), we had a romantic date at this Mongolian and Japanese restaurant in a strip mall, anchored by a K-Mart2.

When we got our fortune cookies, his said “Friends long absent will be returning to you.” (Through the seven years following - through each of our insane girlfriends, which in my case included decidedly non-awesome confrontations with the law - he kept it in his wallet, along with a picture of me he’d taken of me, in the yard of my now-estranged aunt.)

We laughed then, on reading his fortune, because that was how it had always been with us: rotating in and out of each others’ orbits.

Then I opened mine, which read, “You and your wife will be happy in your lives together.” We laughed at that too, because I was entirely out then as “bisexual, erring on the side of women.”

Coming back to him, seven years later, was, among other things, an admission that my fortune had been very, very wrong.

It took awhile for us to figure out that perhaps our fortunes hadn’t been so much “wrong” as “switched.”

Even so, I’ve had moments of ambivalence, in which my brain takes leave of my body, aimlessly wandering its “less traveled” roads. (Or, perhaps more accurately: “roads traveled extensively, but finally abandoned out of dire necessity.”)

And that’s when I need to get back into my own head, cutting through the static of last night’s drinks and dreams, to figure out what that persistent melody is trying to tell me, so I can pull myself back from the detour, and remember “this is the person I married, for all kinds of good reasons stretching far beyond the necessity of abandoning those other failed, landmine-infested roads, and I truly love him.”

__

1 The song is Bitters & Absolut, by The National (from their eponymous record). You can hear it and read the lyrics here here, and/or buy the mp3 from Amazon. No, there’s no affiliate link giving me any kickback from purchases (not that I couldn’t use kickbacks! See pathetic note in column at right, unless you’re reading via RSS!), because I’m too lazy to figure that shit out.

2 Said mall having been built over the literal rubble of one of my numerous, vaguely remembered childhood homes. Only clear memory from that address, on or near Williamsburg, Virginia’s Waller Mill road: when the stepfather I had for a brief period stepped on a nail in the yard, which may or may not have gone all the way through his foot, but there were weird and, considering his artistic rages and otherwise erratic behavior, nonsensical and scrambled allusions to Jesus that, still, I somehow associate with that moment. (And a further tangent: Since the restaurant still exists, we celebrated our 6th wedding anniversary there, in 2007.)

Dreams of a (Media) Literate Presidency: Reflections on an Inauguration Road Trip

“So, what was the highlight?” That’s the question most people have asked since I returned from attending the Inauguration festivities in Washington, D.C. And my answer surprises even me: It is the road trip home, listening for the first time to Barack Obama reading “Dreams of My Father.” We’ve gone from the ridiculous to the sublime. Somehow Americans [...]

[This is a content summary only. Click on the headline for full links and additional content. Thanks!]

Seven things about two brands of whiskey I’d just as soon never drink, and why

(But First, A Ridiculous Preamble)

Tonight I was reading one dude’s entertaining post in response to a “Seven Things No One Knows About You” meme. This led me to recall the fact that a number of perfectly lovely people have “tagged” me with such memes in the past. However, because I am a surly and uncooperative person (the handful of people who will read this already know this about me), I failed to respond. (So too with well-intentioned “blogging awards.”)

First, I don’t have too many secrets. (Particularly from those following me on Twitter. The poor wretches.) Second, if I wanted to make lists of stuff about my life that could be considered freaky (shall we talk about the funeral of my uncle, which had its own bouncer, or about being reported as a missing person in 1993 to Washington State police?), I could do that full time and never run out of material. Third, my best material is precisely the stuff I need to pull together for more sustained narratives - e.g., more short stories and fewer itemized blog posts. (And when I get better at finishing the goddamned stories I start - and, omigawd, start sending out work again - this is the last thing I published - can you say “pathetic”? - I need to move back in the direction of books.)

But whatever. Tonight I figured, “oh why the fuck not.1” So, following are seven things you don’t (or at least, probably don’t) know about me, which, rather than being individually substantive, are tangential but still (one hopes) relevant. I should be able to keep that short and sweet, right?

Seven things about two brands of whiskey I’d just as soon never drink, and why

  1. I am named after the granddaughter of the founder of Southern Comfort, whom my parents met at William and Mary: a woman named Vikki Fowler. (This has something to do with my blog’s title, although that’s only part of it.) I’m told I met her as a baby, and that she may have gone to Africa (on the inspiration of the 1966 film, Born Free, supposedly); in any event, a relative of hers, reached at the Fowler Museum of Cultural History some years ago, had no idea where Vikki ended up; in fact, she said if I ever learned what had become of Vikki, to please let her know. (I’d still really like to know.)
  2. Yet I can’t stand whiskey.
  3. Which is because whiskey was the beverage of choice for one of my most heinous ex-girlfriends, late in 1990 through early 1991.
  4. Who claimed to have a (juvenile) record for attempted murder, and whose behavior was otherwise sufficiently terrorizing that still, from time to time I run her name through her hometown newspaper’s search engines, because what’s more interesting to read than any given town’s police blotter?
  5. Which is how I know that among items she has been arrested for stealing (in addition to violent crime arrests), one of these was, indeed, a bottle of whiskey.
  6. However, that whiskey was not Southern Comfort. It was Black Velvet, which I understand is a) Canadian and b) Also the name of an extraordinarily cheesy late 80s tune recorded by one Alannah Myles.
  7. Who was just her type.

__
1 Not to worry, however. I will not further perpetuate the tagging-with-memes thing; I trust that if you feel like writing something in response to the “seven things” notion, that you will, and that if you don’t, you won’t, and I will love you just the same.

Houston, we have a synopsis!

In case you don’t hear much from me over the next month, the reason - I mean, besides “the election, my children, and drowning in bills” - is as follows (as previously announced here). Word count shown here reflects only my first two days’ work, still quite short of the ideal average of 1,667 words per day (one “wins” if one crosses the finish line by November 30 with at least 50,000 words - see more on NaNoWriMo here), but cut me some slack, this is my first year!

Synopsis & Excerpt: The Book of Badgirl

Again, word count in screen capture is as of late Sunday night. Work in progress title is tentative. For the live page at NaNoWriMo, see the “Novel Info” tab here. And if you want to support the organization by pledging a buck or more (modest, first timer pledge goal for me is $1 per every 1000 words written), click here.

Tagged with: , ,