Dave Mastio (of “Blognetnews” infamy) can suck it. from Victoria Marinelli @ Anachroclysmic 26 Mar 2008 12:31 am
Some time ago, I had the displeasure of finding out that my site’s entire content was being republished, without my permission (and without any links back to my own website), by Blognetnews.com. Its editor, former (and apparently unashamed!) Dubya speechwriter Dave Mastio, who is also, somehow, gainfully employed by The Virginian-Pilot, was apparently scraping all feeds syndicated at RVABlogs.com, creating from this an entire Richmond, Virginia “channel” - again, with no links going back to the sites of origin (either RVABlogs, where various regional bloggers, myself included, are syndicated, or to the original authors’ sites).
Let’s be clear here, that Mastio’s actions do not constitute “fair use.” This is outright theft of content, for the sole purposes of driving traffic to his ad-heavy site. That’s something Jaelithe at The State of Discontent does a great job of explaining in detail. (Seriously, that woman did a ton of research on this matter; many of the links in this post, I first found on her site. Rad work, Jaelithe.)
Now I learn that, in addition to stealing content for his “Richmond channel” (and for many other regional “channels”; see link immediately above for recent material on his “St. Louis channel,” and here for info on his deeds in Iowa; this is, of course, only the tip of the iceberg); he has also created a “Parenting” channel, on which, tonight, one very righteous (and now righteously pissed off) mommyblogger, Erin Kotecki-Vest (a.k.a. QueenofSpain) found her own material being reproduced. (It is, indeed, in honor of Erin, who frequently issues rants about persons who can and should “suck it,” that I have given this blog post the above title.)
Since apparently this guy is still being a huge pain in the blogosphere’s collective ass (and is now specifically messing with bloggers I personally care about), and since I have learned that in some cases, even when contacted by individual blog owners to request removal of their content, Mastio has actually refused - leading another Virginia blogger to take the radical step of disabling all feeds - I feel compelled to reproduce, here, my own previous exchange with Mastio (in the course of which I did get him to not only stop swiping my content, but to delete all my previously swiped content from his database).
Meantime, Liza Sabater (per this message from QueenofSpain on Twitter), is apparently planning to post soon about tools bloggers can use, on a collective basis, to protest Blognetnews; I’m definitely looking forward to that post. Liza points out, also via Twitter, Blognet news obviously isn’t stealing feeds from prominent sites like the Huffington Post “because they have lawyers.” “You and I,” she adds, of individual and independent bloggers, “don’t.”
Here, then, is my exchange from last month with Mastio.
From: Victoria Marinelli
Date: Thu, Feb 14, 2008 at 12:48 AM
Subject: Cease and Desist Immediately
To: editor@blognetnews.com
Dear Thief,
I am aware that you are stealing content for most if not all blogs syndicated by RVABlogs.com. My website at http://victoriamarinelli.com is one of those syndicated by RVABlogs; RVABlogs has my permission to reproduce excerpts of my content; YOU DO NOT.
Remove my feed and all content stolen from victoriamarinelli.com immediately. I look forward to your prompt attention to this matter.
This was his (incredibly condescending and insulting) response:
From: David Mastio
Date: Thu, Feb 14, 2008 at 11:06 AM
Subject: re: Cease and Desist Immediately
To: Victoria Marinelli
Dear Victoria,
I am glad you are aware we are excerpting content from many Richmond blogs. When we built the site more than 8 months ago, we sent emails to every blogger in the system for which we could find an email. A number of Richmond bloggers wrote about it. If you didn’t learn about this until recently it is not from want of effort on our part.
Regardless, I don’t know what that that has to do with RVAblogs other than the rumor I have heard that they trash us behind our backs. Pretty much par for the course from a company that competes with us. We’ve built dozens of sites all over the country and have been aggregating Virginia blogs since 2006 and any claim we’ve taken anything from RVAblogs is a lie.
BNN sites are built on the same area of copyright law that allows Google and other web search engines to exist. It is called “fair use.” Fair use does not require anyone’s permission. It is what allows bloggers to quote hundreds of words from a news story or a book reviewer to quote passages that he or she criticizes.
We’re happy to remove your blog. All our site does is make it easier to find yours.
Best,
Dave Mastio
BlogNetNews.com
We Serve Blogging
Remember to visit our advertisers
I replied as follows (note: where, below, I am quoting Mastio’s previous message, his words appear in italics).
From: Victoria Marinelli
Date: Thu, Feb 14, 2008 at 4:06 PM
Subject: Re: Cease and Desist Immediately
To: editor@blognetnews.com
On Thu, Feb 14, 2008 at 10:06 AM, David Mastio
Dear Victoria,
I am glad you are aware we are excerpting content from many Richmond blogs. When we built the site more than 8 months ago, we sent emails to every blogger in the system for which we could find an email. A number of Richmond bloggers wrote about it. If you didn’t learn about this until recently it is not from want of effort on our part.
My email would not have been in any way difficult to find. I’ve always had a dedicated contact page with a published email address. So you’re either lying or incompetent or both.
Regardless, I don’t know what that that has to do with RVAblogs other than the rumor I have heard that they trash us behind our backs. Pretty much par for the course from a company that competes with us. We’ve built dozens of sites all over the country and have been aggregating Virginia blogs since 2006 and any claim we’ve taken anything from RVAblogs is a lie.
I didn’t overhear or read about anybody “trashing” you. I figured out you were a douchebag all on my own, thanks very much.
BNN sites are built on the same area of copyright law that allows Google and other web search engines to exist. It is called “fair use.”
What you are doing is not fair use and you know it. (Or else why would you bother to claim you had requested permission from those whose content you were stealing in the first place?)
We’re happy to remove your blog.
And I anticipate that I will never find any of my material reproduced on your site ever again.
Victoria Marinelli
P.S. The “remember to visit our advertisers” in your autosig is an especially asinine touch.
The bottom line? This asshole really needs to be confronted, collectively, by all bloggers whose material he is reproducing without permission and solely for his own profit. Rise up, fellow bloggers! And let’s give Mastio his due.